Queer_Zine_Culture_Zines_Perzine_1
Queer_Zine_Culture_Zines_Perzine_1

Tracing Queerness through Zines

Since the emergence of 1930s sci-fi fanzines, the pages of zines have provided a space for young people to share their voice. In this article we trace queer voices in the museum’s zine collection. We spoke to El Affleck, Seleena Laverne Daye and Holly Casio about their practice and how the medium empowers personal stories.

By Lisa der Weduwe | 25.06.25

Archives are incredible repositories of stories, capturing the lives and experiences of people across generations. They are a tangible record of our social and cultural history, that say we are here, we exist! In collecting these stories, or in deciding which stories to collect, archives are not neutral spaces. It is crucial that the voices of those captured within its grey archival boxes, filing cabinets and hard drives are honoured, especially those voices that have historically been excluded or marginalised from archives. 

Joining the museum as an Outreach Champion, El Affleck set out to collect stories of growing up queer. Considering ways in which queer lives are expressed, she built a collection of zines to sit alongside personal photographs and oral histories, to help give shape to the queer experience and voice. The zine format places the authorship completely in the hands of the creator, as El says; “They are about us, by us, and for us. They aren't authorised, approved or censored.” 

Reflecting on the role of queer zines in the collection, MOYC archivist Yeliz Zaifoglu adds; “I think what I really love about our queer zine collection is how playful they are! Where the maker's love for their community and culture come together in a fun and informative way - a stand out quote from one of them has to be 'George Michael is a Butch icon' !!”

We spoke to El and creators Seleena Laverne Daye and Holly Casio, who's zines she archived, about the power of zines and how they have shaped their practice as creatives.

Queer_Zine_Culture_Zines_Perzine_2

Could you introduce yourself and your practice?

Hi, I'm El - I'm a member of Edinburgh Zine Library and a graduate of the Goldsmiths MA Queer History programme. I'm based on the east coast of Scotland and work in museums and galleries. In my spare time I'm usually writing, walking or pottering around looking for plants to eat (in the garden and the wild)!

I'm not sure what I'd call my practice at this point as it's such a funny mix of things. I will say it's definitely been shaped by my time at EZL and the work I've seen the wider zine community do. It's very inspiring being surrounded by folk who are so good at building things from scratch, from individual zines to whole libraries and festivals. When I first joined EZL in 2017 I was thinking more and more about how queer history was everywhere once you started looking for it but I was frustrated that it was something you had to look for. So the two things started mashing together and I realised that if I wanted to see and learn about more queer histories I'd have to take matters into my own hands. Now I'm a queer historian who like making and writing zines, running zine workshops, and talking about zines.

My other interests are queer folk horror, Shakespeare (bit of an outlier) and all kinds of intangible cultural heritage (including youth culture).

 

Could you talk about the perzine as a zine practice?

A perzine is literally a "personal zine". You could argue that all zines are personal in some way or another, but I suppose you can define a perzine by the fact that its primary purpose is to talk about personal experience. Some of them take the form of a memoir, some follow a healing journey, and some are collections of memories about a certain subject.

The practice of zine-making itself is such a flexible thing. Zines are hard to define but I often start with the how they exist in the world rather than their form, though please note that every point of this definition will probably have an exception! Zines are usually DIY, cheaply produced in small quantities with limited distribution. Because they're often quick and dirty they're really easy to make, so pretty egalitarian. They don't exist for profit, and are often gifted or exchanged. They're ephemeral, not necessarily designed to last but they are designed to be read and used! Even if they end up in an archive, I think they should always be read and held and destroyed a little bit.

Perzines specifically might be a way to tell a story that needs told (maybe about growing up queer!), to work through something (a difficult childhood or a traumatic event and the process of healing from that), or to connect to other people through sharing your experiences. I think every perzine has something important to say. 

Perzines can also be a communal practice. This might sound counter-intuitive because the idea of a personal zine sounds individual but I think the act of reading and sharing zines is also part of their making. Again, you'll see that I'm much more about the way they exist in the world than what they look like... one of my favorite things about this project was getting to connect to the zine-makers and ask them loads of questions, something I'm often way too shy to do at zine fairs!

 

Why do you think perzines are so powerful for representing Queer voices? 

Because so many of our stories haven't been told! Or have been told but then wilfully ignored, so we have to be active in telling them to keep them alive. They are about us, by us, and for us. They aren't authorised, approved or censored.

But also I think there's a lot of reasons they're so powerful, and they'll be powerful to different people in different ways!

Zines discuss lots of topics and opinions that are outside the mainstream - sometimes things we don't even have words for the things they discuss until we come across a zine about them. By writing about our own experiences and sharing them we end up articulating these experiences to ourselves. There's something powerful about being able to speak a desire, a fear, a feeling out loud (or on paper), especially if you're queer. A lot of the time it feels like we're left to figure stuff out for ourselves. This was a lonely place for me. Zines and the zine community really did help me feel less alone. Because of this I think zines can still be hugely be powerful if you read them but don't necessarily make them, or if you do make them and keep them in a shoebox under your bed and show no one! 

Perzines (and zines in general) don't have to be finished, coherent, tidy, or 'good'. They're about getting down your ideas, and as long as you've put an idea to paper then you've achieved your purpose. Zines are all about failing. Copied it the wrong way round? That's ok, print it anyway! Messed up your drawing a bit? Thats ok, print it anyway! Lost your your train of thought? Don't worry about it! Blindboy Boatclub speaks about this a lot on his podcast - to make creative work it's important to have space to try things and fail. He also speaks about how play can be really important to creativity, and I think zines can be so playful. They take themselves as seriously as you want them to be taken - I have read so many wonderful silly queer zines! I think again because they are ephemeral you can use them to talk about really serious things without feeling like they'll necessarily be around for ever, but you can also be super irreverent with them. That's a bit of a tangent but to bring it back to failure - there's a lot of theory built around being queer and the art of failure, and I think zines maybe fit into that somehow. About embracing failure, not "succeeding" along traditional routes so having to make your own.

 

Have you seen any recent trends or shifts in perzines?

I'm not sure! I've really enjoyed following the journey Holly Casio's Me and Bruce series has gone on, from the early zines to the podcasts. I'm sure there's a fair few perzines that have gone on to grow into other projects and connect creators with other creators.

I really love seeing perzines being used to collaboratively collect and tell queer histories. West Yorkshire Queer Stories is a great example. I'm generally seeing them used as a tool for recording oral stories which I think is really cool.

It might just be me but I think we'll also see them being used more and more to talk about people's relationship to nature, the landscapes around them and climate emergency. I think as that keeps unfolding we'll see a lot of perzines being used as tools for processing that and organising around it.

Speaking of organising, I've seen a big increase in folk circulating and producing zines about Palestinian liberation at the moment as well, which is a great example of how they can build community, solidarity and resistance.

Queer_Zine_Culture_Zines_Perzine_4

Could you introduce yourself and your practice?
I'm Seleena (She/Her) a zine maker, textile artist, workshop facilitator and retail worker. A lot of my work centres around race, class, gender, sexuality and 90s pop culture, using bright, fun and accessible materials.

What drew you to perzines as a format? 
I always think my zines aren't really perzines but like most of my work they just happen to be about me. My favourite types of zine are fanzines, where people talk about something they love. I think a lot of my zines are centered around a theme or subject that I talk about in a personal matter and so gives an element of a perzine. I just like to talk about stuff haha!

 

Could you introduce Diary of a Teenage Girl Crush?
It's inspired by the teen magazines I read in the mid 90s, like J17, Sugar and Bliss. The title comes from a column/book (by Sara Manning) that featured in J17 called Diary of a Crush (which I don't think I actually ever read) and a song by 00s indie band Angelica called Teenage Girl Crush. It's mostly about the poster boys and girls circa 1995-1998 and the nostalgia of teen crushes and like every zine at the turn of the millenium I read it features a Drew Barrymore 90s collage!


You can find Seleena's website here or follow her on Instagram here.

Queer_Zine_Culture_Zines_Perzine_5

Could you introduce yourself and your practice?

I'm Holly Casio (they/she) and I made queer zines and diy comics. I've been making zines for over 25 years as a way to connect with other queer people to share my art and obsessions. Zines absolutely saved my life. 

What drew you to perzines as a format

I initially made fanzines rather than perzines. I have an obsessive personality and make sense of the world through the lens of fandom and those are my favourite types of zines to make. I remember back in the early 00s so many radical and 'proper' zine distros used to have collecting criteria for zine submissions and fanzines were always excluded because they were seen as not as 'proper' or 'radical' as perzines and political zines. But the thing I love the most about fanzines is that you learn so much more about the person who has made them rather than the object of their fandom. Fanzines ARE perzines!

Could you introduce Me & Bruce?

Me and Bruce is a long running zine series about my obsession with Bruce Springsteen. It started back in 2010 as a zine just for friends, as a way to explain why I, a queer diy feminist punk was somehow obsessed with a cis straight rich white man. I made 10 copies and a friend convinced me to make more and take them to Queer Zine Fest London where the zine just exploded. After selling out the first 3 zine runs, I started making new issues, interrogating class, queerness, gender, and the nature of fandoms and obsession. The zine ran for 4 issues and then culminated in a longer piece of work which was my graphic memoir Looking For Bruce published in 2021. The zine series has allowed me to connect with queer Bruce fans around the world and has led to some wonderful creative projects like appearing on BBC's Soul Music radio show, contributing to Routledge's publication Bruce Springsteen and Popular Music, and it has also led me co-hosting a new 7 part podcast series titled Because the Boss Belongs to Us along with Butch Springsteen drag artist Jesse Lawson. The show is produced by iheart and has taken what felt like silly frivolous musings on fandom to a whole other level, all because of a fanzine I made and not knowing how to just like something a normal amount.

Fanzines 4 eva!


You can find Holly's website here or follow them on Instagram here.